Which provider is a better fit for you? We compare Arval and FlatDrive side by side. Discover differences in prices, inclusions, and contract flexibility.
| Price per month | from CHF 319 | from CHF 430 |
| Google Review | 4.5 / 5.0 | 4.5 / 5.0 |
| Offers | 67 active offers | 43 active offers |
| Insurance | ||
| Liability Insurance | Included Liability Insurance — Arval is the owner of the vehicle and takes out liability insurance; the costs are included in the monthly fee. | Included Liability Insurance — Liability insurance is included in the FlatDrive subscription. |
| Comprehensive (Full Casco) Insurance | Included Comprehensive (Full Casco) Insurance — Arval is the owner of the vehicle and offers comprehensive insurance; the costs are included in the monthly fee. | Included Comprehensive (Full Casco) Insurance — Comprehensive insurance is part of the FlatDrive subscription package. |
| Parking Damage Protection | Included Maximum two times a year. — CarCare covers damages to the parked vehicle caused by unknown third parties, up to two times a year. | Included Parking Damage Protection — Parking damage is included as an insurance component. |
| Glass Breakage Insurance | Included Glass Breakage Insurance — CarCare covers glass breakage on front, side, rear, or roof windows made of glass or glass substitutes. | Included Glass Breakage Insurance — Glass is included as an insurance component. |
| Replacement vehicle | Included Replacement vehicle — The customer is entitled to a replacement vehicle in the agreed category for the duration of maintenance or repair work. | Optional extra Replacement vehicle — The FAQ mention a replacement vehicle during repairs at partner garages Garage Gautschi AG in Langenthal or Lyssach; the T&Cs exclude replacement vehicle costs related to maintenance, repairs, recalls, and similar measures. |
| Price & Conditions | ||
| One-time base fee | Included No flat start fee. | Included No flat start fee. — No membership fees or base fees apply. |
| Deposit | Included No deposit. | Optional extra Deposit possible. — Typically, a deposit of CHF 500 is required at the start of the lease; FlatDrive can also set a higher deposit individually. |
| Early termination | Included Early termination — No free monthly cancellation, but contractually regulated special termination cases. | Included Early termination is possible, but not free. — An early termination is possible with FlatDrive's consent; in this case, the price will be recalculated based on the actual duration, and any additional kilometers will be charged separately. |
| Price guarantee during term | Included Price guarantee during term — Changes in VAT or new charges may be passed on to the customer. | Not included Price guarantee during term — FlatDrive can adjust the monthly fees in case of changes to vehicle taxes, fees, premiums, etc. with one month's notice. |
| Mileage & Duration | ||
| Included kilometers | Included Included kilometers — The mileage is agreed upon in the contract and will be settled at the end. | Included Included kilometers — The service includes a set number of free kilometers per month, depending on the package. |
| Minimum term | Included Minimum term — A fixed service duration applies, starting with the handover of the vehicle. | Included Minimum term — The minimum or contractual duration agreed in the contract applies; for vehicles, it is usually 3 months according to the FAQ. |
| Cancellation period after minimum term | Included Early termination only in exceptional cases. | Included Cancellation period after minimum term — After the minimum contract duration, termination can be made in writing with a notice period of 30 days, even mid-month. |
| Extra kilometer costs | Included Extra kilometer costs — In case of exceeding, billing will occur at the rates specified in the contract. | Included Additional kilometers are contractually regulated. — Additional kilometers are charged at the rate specified in the contract. |
| Credit for unused kilometers | Included Unused kilometers are reimbursed, but with a cap. — In case of underutilization, a settlement will be made according to the contractually defined rates; a maximum of 10,000 fewer kilometers will be refunded. | Not included There is no refund for untraveled kilometers. — Unused subscription kilometers are not credited. |
| Mileage Adjustment | Not included Mileage Adjustment — No ongoing adjustment of the agreed mileage. | Optional extra An adjustment is possible, but not regarded as a free customer right. — In case of significant overage of subscription kilometers, FlatDrive may exceptionally charge for the additional kilometers and/or adjust the kilometer package on the next invoice. |
| Adjustable mileage package | Not included Adjustable mileage package — No mid-year package change is expressly provided. | Optional extra Mid-year adjustment is possible, but managed by FlatDrive. — FlatDrive can adjust the mileage package in case of significant overage on the next invoice. |
| Registration & Admin | ||
| Vehicle Taxes | Included Vehicle Taxes — The vehicle tax is included in the agreed monthly fee. | Included Vehicle Taxes — FlatDrive covers the traffic tax. |
| Registration | Included Registration — Fees for the first registration of the vehicle are included in the monthly charge. | Included Registration — FlatDrive covers the registration fees. |
| Service & Maintenance | Included Service & Maintenance — Periodic maintenance according to manufacturer specifications is included in the monthly fee. | Included Service & Maintenance — FlatDrive covers the costs for services and the maintenance required by the manufacturer. |
| MFK | Included MFK — Legally required technical inspections are included in the monthly fee. | Included MFK — Official regulations such as technical inspections must be adhered to; FlatDrive covers all costs associated with driving on public Swiss roads as well as maintenance costs. |
| License Plate | Included License Plate — First registration fees yes, license plate not explicitly mentioned. | Included The license plate is generally included, the canton change costs extra. — The vehicles come standard with a Bernese license plate; a plate from the canton of residence can be ordered for an additional cost. |
| Motorway vignette | Included Initial vignette | Included Motorway vignette — A valid highway sticker is included. |
| Reminder Fees / Payment Delay | Included Reminder Fees / Payment Delay — First reminder free, each additional reminder CHF 30. | Included Reminder fees are provided. — In case of payment delay, the customer owes the statutory default interest; additionally, reminder and termination fees may be charged according to the fee schedule. |
| Processing fee for damages | Included Processing fee for damages — There are financial consequences for damages, but no standard flat damage fee. | Included Damage-related processing costs are provided. — Additional costs may be charged for incorrect or incomplete damage documentation, as well as for unreported damages. |
| Tires | ||
| Tyre Change Service | Included Tyre Change Service | Included Tyre Change Service — FlatDrive covers the costs for tire changes. |
| Tyre Storage | Not included Tyre Storage | Included Tyre Storage — The storage is free for the customer, but the service takes place at authorized partners. |
| Summer Tyres | Included Summer Tyres — The costs for purchasing tires, as far as they become necessary through normal use, are included in the monthly fee. | Included Summer tires are covered as part of the tires, unless all-season tires are used. — FlatDrive determines whether the vehicle is equipped with summer and winter tires or all-season tires. |
| Winter Tyres | Included Winter Tyres — The customer must have winter/summer tires changed accordingly; the costs for purchasing necessary tires are included. | Included Winter tires are covered as part of the tires, unless all-season tires are used. — FlatDrive determines whether the vehicle is equipped with summer and winter tires or all-season tires. |
| Tire wear | Included Tire wear — Tire purchase for normal use is included in the monthly fee. | Included Tire wear — Normal tire-related operational services are included in the subscription. |
| Contract Flexibility & Fees | ||
| Trade-in old car | Not included Trade-in old car | Included A trade-in is generally possible. — The vehicle can be exchanged in consultation with partner garages; the amount will be paid out and not offset against subscription invoices. |
| Home delivery | Included Home delivery — Home delivery is included. | Optional extra CHF 195.00 — Home delivery is available for an additional fee; delivery kilometers are already counted towards the subscription. |
| Pickup on return | Not included Pickup on return — In case of late return, Arval may arrange for the vehicle to be picked up at the customer's expense. | Optional extra Pickup is possible, but not free. — Upon request, FlatDrive picks up the vehicle at the customer's residence; costs are charged according to the rate. |
| Services | ||
| 24/7 Assistance | Included 24/7 Assistance — Arval Assistance provides a 24-hour service for breakdowns or claims across Europe. | Included 24/7 Assistance — The 24/7 breakdown service is included in the subscription. |
| Digital access | Included Digital access — Driver Center and electronic communication. | Included Digital access — Booking and communication are done through the website, email, and contact with FlatDrive, but no dedicated digital access as a service component is described. |
| App available | Included App available | Not included App available — No app publicly listed. |
| Digital Damage Report | Included Digital Damage Report — Claims must be reported in writing and with a European accident report. | Included Digital Damage Report — The damage report must be submitted in writing, at least by e-mail. |
| Running Costs | ||
| AdBlue included | Optional extra No separate AdBlue arrangement. | Not included AdBlue included |
| Wiper fluid / Supplies | Optional extra Wiper fluid / Supplies — Maintenance is included, but individual everyday operating materials are not. | Not included Wiper fluid / Supplies |
| Return | ||
| Vehicle cleaning on return | Optional extra Vehicle cleaning on return — The vehicle must be returned in proper condition; no explicit cleaning obligation is described separately. | Optional extra Cleaning is the customer's return obligation. — The vehicle must be returned clean and fully fueled. |
| Additional costs for heavy dirt | Optional extra Additional costs for heavy dirt — Damages or conditions not corresponding to normal wear will be charged to the customer. | Optional extra Severe dirtiness is chargeable. — Costs for exterior and interior cleaning are charged according to the fee schedule or actual effort. |
| Additional costs for hair / smell | Optional extra Additional costs for hair / smell — Damages or conditions not corresponding to normal wear will be charged to the customer. | Optional extra Pet hair and odors can incur significant additional costs. — Transporting animals without a transport box is considered pollution; special cleanings will be charged based on effort, and if odors cannot be completely eliminated, FlatDrive may charge up to 10 percent of the vehicle's value. |
| Additional costs for smoking | Optional extra Additional costs for smoking — Damage or conditions not corresponding to normal wear will be charged to the customer. | Optional extra Smoking is not allowed and is chargeable. — Smoking in the vehicle is expressly considered pollution; smoke and fire damage will be charged, and in case of a non-fully removable odor, FlatDrive may charge up to 10 percent of the vehicle's value. |
| Fuel/Charge level on return | Optional extra Fuel/Charge level on return — No explicit requirement for fuel or charge level. | Optional extra The energy condition at return is expressly regulated. — The vehicle must be returned full. |
| Usage & Abroad | ||
| Foreign travel | Included Foreign travel — The vehicle may be driven in the countries listed on the international insurance certificate. | Included Foreign travel is generally allowed, but geographically restricted. — Usage is permitted in Europe, except in the Russian Federation, Belarus, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Moldova, Ukraine, and Kazakhstan, as well as in official war zones according to the EDA. |
| Business use allowed | Not included Commercial use is excluded. — The vehicle may only be used for private purposes. | Included Business use allowed — FlatDrive also enters into contracts with legal entities; the terms and conditions do not include a general restriction to purely private use. |
| Driver Profile | ||
| Minimum age | 20 years — Other vehicle users must be at least 20 years old. | 18 years — FlatDrive ties usage to residence, creditworthiness, and driver's license, not to a specifically stated age limit. |
| Additional Drivers | Included Additional Drivers — Temporary provision is allowed for persons residing in Switzerland, at least 20 years old and holding a valid driver's license. | Included Additional drivers are allowed, but the customer is responsible for their behavior. — The vehicle may be entrusted to other authorized users, provided they meet the same criteria as customers. |
| Driving lessons allowed | Not included Use for driving lessons is excluded. | Optional extra Driving lessons are only possible on selected vehicles. — Individuals with a learner's permit and required supervision may drive vehicles selected by FlatDrive. |
| Pets allowed | Included Pets allowed — The vehicle must be returned in a clean condition. | Optional extra Practically only with transport box. — Pets are not explicitly prohibited; without a transport box, transport is considered as pollution with cost implications. |
| Smoking allowed | Included Smoking allowed — The vehicle must be returned in clean condition. | Not included Smoking is prohibited. — The vehicles are non-smoking vehicles; smoking in the vehicle is considered pollution. |
| Angebote anzeigen | Angebote anzeigen |
This comparison is based on daily inventory data and the providers' official contract conditions. We assess objectively according to fixed criteria such as value for money, inclusions, and transparency.