Which provider is a better fit for you? We compare Carvolution and FlatDrive side by side. Discover differences in prices, inclusions, and contract flexibility.
| Price per month | from CHF 425 | from CHF 430 |
| Google Review | 4.2 / 5.0 | 4.5 / 5.0 |
| Offers | 81 active offers | 43 active offers |
| Insurance | ||
| Liability Insurance | Included Liability Insurance — Liability insurance is arranged through Carvolution; coverage up to a maximum of CHF 100 million for bodily injury and property damage to third parties. | Included Liability Insurance — Liability insurance is included in the FlatDrive subscription. |
| Comprehensive (Full Casco) Insurance | Included Comprehensive (Full Casco) Insurance — Carvolution has taken out a comprehensive insurance for the vehicle; it covers the repair costs for restoring the vehicle. | Included Comprehensive (Full Casco) Insurance — Comprehensive insurance is part of the FlatDrive subscription package. |
| Deductible full coverage (CHF) | Optional extra Depending on the package: 250 CHF, 500 CHF or 1'000 CHF. — The customer bears the contractually agreed deductible per claim; according to Carvolution, CHF 250, CHF 500, or CHF 1,000 can be chosen depending on the offer. | No information 1000 (CHF 1’000 per collision damage; for individuals with a probationary driver's license or learner's permit with required supervision CHF 2’000 per event.) |
| Parking Damage Protection | Optional extra Parking damage is an optional additional service. — Parking damages can be included for an additional fee, with a maximum of two claims per year without deductible. | Included Parking Damage Protection — Parking damage is included as an insurance component. |
| Deductible parking damage (CHF) | Optional extra Only with separately included parking damage insurance. — With included parking damage insurance without deductible. | No information CHF 500 per event. |
| Glass Breakage Insurance | Included Glass is covered by the comprehensive solution. — The comprehensive insurance covers repair costs including headlights; Carvolution recommends a glass additional insurance. | Included Glass Breakage Insurance — Glass is included as an insurance component. |
| Replacement vehicle | Included Replacement vehicle — In case of necessary repairs or an accident, Carvolution provides a replacement vehicle for the duration of the repairs. | Optional extra Replacement vehicle — The FAQ mention a replacement vehicle during repairs at partner garages Garage Gautschi AG in Langenthal or Lyssach; the T&Cs exclude replacement vehicle costs related to maintenance, repairs, recalls, and similar measures. |
| Gross Negligence Cover | Optional extra The inclusion is an additional service. — Gross negligence can be included for an additional compensation. | Not included Gross Negligence Cover — Damage caused by gross negligence may be charged to the customer; furthermore, FlatDrive can terminate the contract immediately. |
| Passenger accident insurance | Included Passenger accident insurance — Carvolution has taken out passenger insurance; it covers medical expenses, disability capital up to CHF 80,000, and death capital up to CHF 30,000. | Not included Passenger accident insurance — No separate passenger accident insurance stated. |
| Price & Conditions | ||
| One-time base fee | Included No flat start fee. | Included No flat start fee. — No membership fees or base fees apply. |
| Deposit | Optional extra The deposit is case-dependent and contractually regulated. — Carvolution may require a deposit before delivery or during the contract term; amount as per contract. | Optional extra Deposit possible. — Typically, a deposit of CHF 500 is required at the start of the lease; FlatDrive can also set a higher deposit individually. |
| Deposit | Optional extra The down payment is optional and contractually regulated. — Before delivery, the first two monthly installments and, if agreed, a down payment must be paid. | Not included Deposit — Monthly subscription fees yes, but no separate upfront payment. |
| Fee for subscription change | Optional extra Changes may incur costs, but no flat subscription change fee is mentioned in the T&Cs. — Changes to the mileage package result in adjusted subscription fees; additional charges may apply according to the tariff conditions. | No information Fee for subscription change |
| Early termination | Included No free short-term cancellation, only according to the terms and conditions. — Early termination is possible for a valid reason; withdrawal before takeover may incur costs. | Included Early termination is possible, but not free. — An early termination is possible with FlatDrive's consent; in this case, the price will be recalculated based on the actual duration, and any additional kilometers will be charged separately. |
| Automatic renewal | Included Cancelable monthly after minimum duration, otherwise automatic continuation until maximum duration. — If the contract is not terminated at the end of the minimum service duration, it will continue until the maximum service duration. | Not included An automatic extension is not generally guaranteed. — For fixed-term contracts, an extension is only possible with FlatDrive's consent. |
| Mileage & Duration | ||
| Included kilometers | Included Included kilometers — The monthly subscription kilometers are specified in the contract. | Included Included kilometers — The service includes a set number of free kilometers per month, depending on the package. |
| Minimum term | Included Minimum term — Minimum and maximum service durations can be agreed upon. | Included Minimum term — The minimum or contractual duration agreed in the contract applies; for vehicles, it is usually 3 months according to the FAQ. |
| Cancellation period after minimum term | Included Cancellation period after minimum term — After the minimum service duration, monthly termination with a notice period of 30 days to the effective date is possible. | Included Cancellation period after minimum term — After the minimum contract duration, termination can be made in writing with a notice period of 30 days, even mid-month. |
| Extra kilometer costs | Included Additional kilometers are contractually regulated. — Additional kilometers are charged according to the contractually agreed rate. | Included Additional kilometers are contractually regulated. — Additional kilometers are charged at the rate specified in the contract. |
| Mileage Adjustment | Optional extra Mileage adjustment is possible, but requires approval. — Changes to the agreed number of kilometers per month can be arranged upon request during the contract term, provided Carvolution agrees. | Optional extra An adjustment is possible, but not regarded as a free customer right. — In case of significant overage of subscription kilometers, FlatDrive may exceptionally charge for the additional kilometers and/or adjust the kilometer package on the next invoice. |
| Adjustable mileage package | Optional extra Mid-year adjustment is not automatic, but only possible with consent. — Adjustments during the subscription period are possible upon request, provided Carvolution agrees. | Optional extra Mid-year adjustment is possible, but managed by FlatDrive. — FlatDrive can adjust the mileage package in case of significant overage on the next invoice. |
| Registration & Admin | ||
| Vehicle Taxes | Included Vehicle Taxes — Carvolution is responsible for the payment of periodic vehicle taxes. | Included Vehicle Taxes — FlatDrive covers the traffic tax. |
| Registration | Included Registration — Carvolution ensures the redemption, license plate, and vehicle registration. | Included Registration — FlatDrive covers the registration fees. |
| Service & Maintenance | Included Service & Maintenance — Maintenance and servicing are ensured by Carvolution. | Included Service & Maintenance — FlatDrive covers the costs for services and the maintenance required by the manufacturer. |
| MFK | Included MFK — Official regulations such as technical inspections must be adhered to, and maintenance is ensured by Carvolution. | Included MFK — Official regulations such as technical inspections must be adhered to; FlatDrive covers all costs associated with driving on public Swiss roads as well as maintenance costs. |
| License Plate | Included License Plate — Carvolution takes care of the license plate before handover. | Included The license plate is generally included, the canton change costs extra. — The vehicles come standard with a Bernese license plate; a plate from the canton of residence can be ordered for an additional cost. |
| Motorway vignette | Included The first vignette is included. — Carvolution equips the vehicle with the highway sticker for the current year. | Included Motorway vignette — A valid highway sticker is included. |
| Reminder Fees / Payment Delay | Included Reminder Fees / Payment Delay — 2nd reminder CHF 30, 3rd reminder CHF 50; further non-payment may incur additional costs and immediate termination. | Included Reminder fees are provided. — In case of payment delay, the customer owes the statutory default interest; additionally, reminder and termination fees may be charged according to the fee schedule. |
| Processing fee for damages | Optional extra Processing fee for damages — Additional fees and expenses, such as cleaning charges or appraisal costs, are subject to tariff regulations. | Included Damage-related processing costs are provided. — Additional costs may be charged for incorrect or incomplete damage documentation, as well as for unreported damages. |
| Tires | ||
| Tyre Change Service | Included Tire change is part of the car subscription. — The required tire changes are ensured by Carvolution and carried out after consultation with a designated service partner. | Included Tyre Change Service — FlatDrive covers the costs for tire changes. |
| Tyre Storage | Included Tyre Storage — Organized by Carvolution or its partners. | Included Tyre Storage — The storage is free for the customer, but the service takes place at authorized partners. |
| Summer Tyres | Included Summer Tyres — The tires are ensured by Carvolution. | Included Summer tires are covered as part of the tires, unless all-season tires are used. — FlatDrive determines whether the vehicle is equipped with summer and winter tires or all-season tires. |
| Winter Tyres | Included Winter Tyres — The tires are ensured by Carvolution; legal regulations must be followed. | Included Winter tires are covered as part of the tires, unless all-season tires are used. — FlatDrive determines whether the vehicle is equipped with summer and winter tires or all-season tires. |
| Tire wear | Included Tire wear — The tires are part of the subscription; standard tires are ensured by Carvolution. | Included Tire wear — Normal tire-related operational services are included in the subscription. |
| Contract Flexibility & Fees | ||
| Test drive | Included A test drive is possible. | Not included Test drive — A test drive is not planned in advance. |
| Trade-in old car | Included Trade-in old car — Trade-in service. | Included A trade-in is generally possible. — The vehicle can be exchanged in consultation with partner garages; the amount will be paid out and not offset against subscription invoices. |
| Home delivery | Optional extra CHF 195.00 | Optional extra CHF 195.00 — Home delivery is available for an additional fee; delivery kilometers are already counted towards the subscription. |
| Pickup on return | Not included Pickup on return — In case of late return, Carvolution can collect the vehicle at the customer's expense. | Optional extra Pickup is possible, but not free. — Upon request, FlatDrive picks up the vehicle at the customer's residence; costs are charged according to the rate. |
| Services | ||
| 24/7 Assistance | Included 24/7 Assistance — Carvolution provides a 24h breakdown service as part of the vehicle subscription. | Included 24/7 Assistance — The 24/7 breakdown service is included in the subscription. |
| Digital access | Included The subscription is digitally supported. — Carvolution provides an app and allows notifications via app or email. | Included Digital access — Booking and communication are done through the website, email, and contact with FlatDrive, but no dedicated digital access as a service component is described. |
| App available | Included App available — Carvolution refers to the Carvolution app for support and reports. | Not included App available — No app publicly listed. |
| Digital Damage Report | Included Digital damage reporting is provided. — Incidents should be reported by email or, if possible, via the Carvolution app. | Included Digital Damage Report — The damage report must be submitted in writing, at least by e-mail. |
| Running Costs | ||
| Fuel discount | Included Fuel discount — Carvolution offers an AVIA fuel card (e.g., 5 cents discount per liter). | Not included Fuel discount — No fuel or charging card specified. |
| Electric discount (Vehicles) | Included Electric discount (Vehicles) — Carvolution offers an evpass charging card (e.g., 5 cents discount per kWh). | Not included Electric discount (Vehicles) — No fuel card or charging card specified. |
| Charging card / Charge access | Included Charging card / Charge access — Carvolution offers an evpass charging card. | Not included Charging card / Charge access |
| Return | ||
| Vehicle cleaning on return | Optional extra Cleaning costs may apply according to tariff regulations. — The T&Cs require a return with a full tank or sufficiently charged; an explicit cleaning obligation is primarily included in return standards/rate terms. | Optional extra Cleaning is the customer's return obligation. — The vehicle must be returned clean and fully fueled. |
| Additional costs for heavy dirt | Optional extra Severe dirtiness may incur charges. — Cleaning fees and other costs are subject to tariff regulations. | Optional extra Severe dirtiness is chargeable. — Costs for exterior and interior cleaning are charged according to the fee schedule or actual effort. |
| Additional costs for hair / smell | Optional extra Pet hair or odors may fall under cleaning fees. — Not explicitly stated in the T&Cs; any cleaning costs are subject to tariff regulations. | Optional extra Pet hair and odors can incur significant additional costs. — Transporting animals without a transport box is considered pollution; special cleanings will be charged based on effort, and if odors cannot be completely eliminated, FlatDrive may charge up to 10 percent of the vehicle's value. |
| Additional costs for smoking | Optional extra Smoke odor may incur costs according to tariff regulations. — Not explicitly stated in the T&Cs; any cleaning costs are subject to tariff regulations. | Optional extra Smoking is not allowed and is chargeable. — Smoking in the vehicle is expressly considered pollution; smoke and fire damage will be charged, and in case of a non-fully removable odor, FlatDrive may charge up to 10 percent of the vehicle's value. |
| Fuel/Charge level on return | Optional extra The return condition is expressly regulated. — The vehicle must be returned fully fueled or, for electric vehicles, with sufficiently charged batteries. | Optional extra The energy condition at return is expressly regulated. — The vehicle must be returned full. |
| Usage & Abroad | ||
| Foreign travel | Included Foreign trips are generally allowed. — The vehicle may be driven abroad; insurance coverage applies in Europe and in the countries bordering the Mediterranean, with exceptions. | Included Foreign travel is generally allowed, but geographically restricted. — Usage is permitted in Europe, except in the Russian Federation, Belarus, Georgia, Armenia, Azerbaijan, Moldova, Ukraine, and Kazakhstan, as well as in official war zones according to the EDA. |
| Business use allowed | Not included Business use allowed — The vehicle may only be used for private purposes. | Included Business use allowed — FlatDrive also enters into contracts with legal entities; the terms and conditions do not include a general restriction to purely private use. |
| Driver Profile | ||
| Minimum age | No information 18 (A conclusion requires the ability to act and a valid driver's license; the under-23 rule is insurance-relevant.) | 18 years — FlatDrive ties usage to residence, creditworthiness, and driver's license, not to a specifically stated age limit. |
| Minimum license requirement | Included A valid driver's license is a mandatory requirement. | No information A valid driver's license is required. — A valid indefinite driver's license from Switzerland or Liechtenstein, at least category B, is required; individuals with a probationary license or a learner's permit with supervision may use selected vehicles. |
| Additional Drivers | Included Additional Drivers — Third parties may use the vehicle, provided they meet the same conditions as the customer. | Included Additional drivers are allowed, but the customer is responsible for their behavior. — The vehicle may be entrusted to other authorized users, provided they meet the same criteria as customers. |
| Driving lessons allowed | Not included Driving lessons allowed — Normal driving training is prohibited; only WAB training drives may be allowed with written confirmation. | Optional extra Driving lessons are only possible on selected vehicles. — Individuals with a learner's permit and required supervision may drive vehicles selected by FlatDrive. |
| Pets allowed | Not included Pets allowed — Transporting animals is prohibited; violation may result in significant cleaning costs. | Optional extra Practically only with transport box. — Pets are not explicitly prohibited; without a transport box, transport is considered as pollution with cost implications. |
| Angebote anzeigen | Angebote anzeigen |
This comparison is based on daily inventory data and the providers' official contract conditions. We assess objectively according to fixed criteria such as value for money, inclusions, and transparency.